Should you still pay credit card charge offs or settle the account if they both have the same negative results on your credit report?

already exists.

Would you like to merge this question into it?

already exists as an alternate of this question.

Would you like to make it the primary and merge this question into it?

exists and is an alternate of .

The simple answer is..a settlement is an agreement between the creditor and debtor for repayment of a specified amount of the debt, thereby ending the transaction (hopefully). A charge off is the action taken by the creditor after an account has been in default for 180 days. The debt is still owed and the creditor has several options to collect monies owed, including legal remedies such as a lawsuit.

So if it is then paid will it show settled on the credit report? And if so is it a big difference between the two as far as credit score goes?

If you decide to just ignore the debt, you still owe it to someone. A charge-off with a $0 balance looks much better to potential lenders than a charge-off with a $5000 balance that's still in collections. Plus, the creditor (or any collection agency willing to buy your debt for pennies on the dollar) can come after you in court YEARS later. Here's an example: You owe Sears $4000 on your Sears Card but haven't paid in 8 months. Sears charges the account off and holds the paperwork (they have up to 6 years in most states to come after you). Joe's Collection Agency goes to Sears and buys your account from them for $160. Now, Joe's can call you and offer a settlement for $2000 and still make a boatload of cash. The charge-off shows as "sold/transferred" on your credit report, and you also have a charge-off from Joe's with a $0 balance. What I would do: Talk to the creditor and see if there's a way to settle out of the account and have it removed from your reports. It's often called a "pay for removal". Just make sure you get their promise in writing.
The question might be better phrased "Should I pay the balance in full or pay the amount of the settlement offer?
Paying the balance is ALWAYS better. Why: To a risk manager, a person who pays their balances in full is a much better risk than a person who does not.
A settlement, on the other hand, though necessary for some, is not the preferred choice. Why? Several reasons;
1) By definition, a settlement is some amount less than the full balance. Before you pay any settlement, first have IN YOUR HAND a copy of the settlement offer from the firm making the offer. If you do NOT have the hard copy in your hand, it is YOUR word against theirs and the next collection agency will be after you again in a few months for the difference between what you paid and the balance - which will very likely be higher because of added interest & cost of collections. This can haunt a consumer for years.
2) Any time you agree to a settlement and the difference between what you paid and what you owed is equal to or greater than $600., the IRS requires the financial institution that "gifted" you the difference must send you a 1099C at year's end listing the amount of that gift. You then count this "gift" as taxable income for the year in which the settlement was paid.
3) For those who are concerned about their credit report scores, it is easier to remove a "balance paid in full" from the credit bureau report than it is to remove a "legally settled for less than the full balance".
Think about a settlement carefully before you decide. You cannot go back later and pay the difference. I would evaluate the amount of my savings in the settlement against the my tax liability at year's end and the increased cost of interest that I will pay over the next 7.5 years. My credit score is very likely going to drop as a result of my settlement.Decide wisely. Pay it off. You can also try to negotiate the removal of the charge off upon final payment of the balance. Either way you don't want the company to continue to report to your credit report with a balance. The sooner you pay it off the sooner you have a chance of removing it off your credit report.
92 people found this useful

Should you let charge-offs stay on your credit report?

Charge-Offs Here are opinions on whether you should let charge-offs stay on your credit report: . It really depends on how long ago the debt was and what you are looking to do now. Paying the charged off debt will not increase your credit score, the damage is already done. However if you are loo (MORE)

Should you pay a charge off that is listed on your credit report?

If you legitimately owe the debt, you should pay it, regardless of the statute of limitations or any adverse affect of it being on your credit report. A debt is a debt, and you have a moral obligation to repay it if it is legitimate and you are able to do so. Check and see what you statute of limi (MORE)

If you pay off your past due accounts will the negative report remain on your credit and how does that look when you apply for a new account?

Paying off derogatory items listed on your credit report does NOT cause those items to be deleted. The statute of limitations, which is generally 7 years from the date of last activity still applies. It is better to have paid collection or charge off accounts than unpaid. After a certain amount of t (MORE)

If you owe a credit card company and your credit report says that the account is charged off do you still have to pay the debt?

Sorry to disagree with the previous poster. You do indeed still have to pay. A charge off is a term used by the original creditor to indicate the debt is being removed from their books. That is done for tax purposes, so it can be claimed as a loss. The account will be sold to a third party who will (MORE)

What is a charge-off on your credit report?

Answer . \nCharge off is a shortened version of "charged off to profit and loss". This is an internal accounting term for activity creditors take on defaulted accounts. For a consumer's purposes charge off = collection account. This is a defaulted debt that shows as a derogatory account on you (MORE)

If you pay off all of your credit accounts and close most charge cards but leave the major cards open will it hurt your credit score?

No it won't. Your credit is only hurt if you dont make payments on time and if you keep applying for things that requires credit inquiries on regular basis. If you close all your cards and just leave the major ones open it won't have any effect on your credit score. The longer you go without applyin (MORE)

If a person has numerous charge-offs on their credit report and wants to pay it off is it better to pay these in full or is it OK to settle?

Charged off accounts are classified as derogatory items. Even if paid in full, they will remain on your credit report for the legally allowable term (usually 7 years). While it may "look" better to have paid the full amount rather than settled the debt, the deductions are the same. Make your decisio (MORE)

Should you pay third-party collection agencies for your charged-off credit cards?

Opinions from contributors: Opinion It depends. Do you owe the money? Can you pay the money? Did you successfully complete a bankruptcy in which the debt wasincluded? Was the law broken in any way while the original owner ofthe debt or the third party was trying to collect the money? If you ans (MORE)

If you have a charged off credit card will it only stay on your credit report for 10 years?

All derogatory credit, including late payments as well as account written to profit and loss (which show on your credit file as either an R9 for Revolving Charge off or I9 - Installment Charge-off) can be removed after 7 years. Bankrutpcy Chapter 7 - stays on for 10 years. You must be proactive at t (MORE)

Are you responsible for paying credit card debt after it was charged off and the account sold?

Answer . \nAbsolutely. "Charge off" is a term used by the original creditor when removing the account from their books and listing it as a loss for taxation purposes. In most cases the account is sold for pennies on the dollar, to a third party agency who will pursue colletion of the debt. The be (MORE)

If your credit card account was charged off in 2002 but the credit bureaus are reporting a last reported date of 2005 is this legal and can it be corrected?

Creditors can and often will update negative information. It is my understanding that they have the right to do so. If there is no activity from the creditor for seven years, the charge off will drop off your credit report. Also, charge off's need to be paid if you want to get good credit. You often (MORE)

What does it mean when an account has been charged off on a credit report?

Answer . Charged off is a shortened version of "charged off to profit and loss". This is an accounting term which describes actions taken by creditors to avoid showing loss (red ink) on their books. For a consumer, charge off is the same as a collection account. It is a defaulted debt that rem (MORE)

If your credit card account was charged off and sold to a collection agency should the credit card company report it as being paid satisfactory or a collection charge off?

Answer . \nHaving your credit card or any other account 'charged off' or reported as a 'collection' means that your balence had not been paid satifactory up until that point. If you pay these derogatory accounts after they have been charged off or reported as a collection account, and one should (MORE)

If you pay a charged-off account does it stay on your credit report for another seven years?

Answer . It will probably still show up as a late pay, but that is far better than a write-off. Before you pay it off tell them that you got into a little of a financial bind and couldn't make payments but now that you can you would like them to remove any indication that you paid late in exchang (MORE)

How do you pay credit card charge-offs?

Answer . \nI am a professional debt collector and would say the best answer would be to either contact your credit card company and see to whom they sold the debt, as they no longer own the debt and therefore can not help you rectify the situation. The other option would be to pull a credit rep (MORE)

Are you still liable for a debt after a credit card company charges off your account?

Yes, a charge off does not mean a debt is invalid nor uncollectible. The term is used by creditors to indicate a debt that they believe is not collectible under normal procedures and they are clearing the debt from their books for taxation and operational purposes. The OC will then refer (or sell) t (MORE)

What can you do if a credit card issuer is planning to sue for an account that was never charged off or reported to the credit bureaus?

Answer . \nAny creditor/lender may file a lawsuit against a defaulted account at any time. The account need not be designated a charge off nor be reported to credit bureaus before litigation can be pursued. \n. \nThe best choice is for the debtor to seek advice from an attorney who is qualified (MORE)

Should you pay off a debt that is already listed on your credit report as charged off?

Answer . \nA debt being designated as a "charge off" does not mean the debt is not valid and collectible.\n. \nCollection of the debt will still be pursued either through an agency contracted by the original creditor or a third party purchaser.\n. \nThe creditor/collector has the option of fil (MORE)

If your credit report shows an account as closed or charged off can the bank or someone that has purchased the debt still collect on the account?

Answer . The charging or writing off of a debt is only a required accounting entry by the creditor. . It does not effect you, or change the amount you owe, or that you owe it. . It does not change any of the legal methods to force collection that were available before making the entry.. It d (MORE)

Are you responsible for paying credit card debt after it was charged off and the account sold and what is the law on this?

Yes, you are still liable on the debt. Unless the debt is beyond the statute of limitations (which varies by state) or it is discharged in bankruptcy, you are likely to be liable on the debt. If the debt is forgiven/cancelled (you would then not be liable) then you will likely receive a 1099-C in th (MORE)

When is a credit card account charge off wrong?

The charging or writing off of a debt is only a required accounting entry by the creditor. . It does not effect you, or change the amount you owe, or that you owe it. . It does not change any of the legal methods to force collection that were available before making the entry.. It does not chan (MORE)

Do you have to pay taxes on credit card charge offs?

Yes. Cancellation of debt is the same as income. Discussed many times here, frequently with Qs like write off or charge off in them. . A 1099-C is given by someone who has discharged or forgiven a debt to you.. It is reported to the IRS by them on that form. (So your reporting it is telling (MORE)

If you pay a charged off credit card how long does it take to go on your credit report?

Your charged off and now paid off card will show that you've had a charge off and that you've paid it off. It will also indicate if you paid an amount less than what the original debt was, if you came to that agreement with the creditor. The item should show on your credit report for 7 years from th (MORE)

Will it improve your credit score if you pay off a credit card with a negative credit report standing?

Paying a collection account can actually reduce your credit score, here's why: The credit scoring software looks at the date of last activity on the credit report to determine what effect it will have on the credit score. Collection agencies will update your credit report to say "Paid Collection" wh (MORE)

Can you get a credit card to pay off your overdrawn bank account?

In principle you can; you can get a cash advance from a credit card and use that to pay off the bank account, the problem is that the interest from the credit card is likely to be higher than the bank charges. It's probably best to try and arrange a loan with the bank.

Can you still settle a debt with the credit card company after a charge off?

The charging or writing off of a debt is only a required accounting entry by the creditor. . It does not effect you, or change the amount you owe, or that you owe it. . It does not change any of the legal methods to force collection that were available before making the entry.. It does not chan (MORE)

What is a Charge-off in a credit report?

A charged off account is similar to a collection on your credit report. The creditor has written off the debt owed and closed the account. The debt is still valid though and can be collected on. The charge off will lower your credit score unless removed. You can dispute a charge off and this give th (MORE)

How do you get charge off your credit report?

You can remove a charge off by either disputing it to the credit bureaus are negotiating the removal with the original creditor. The credit bureaus have 30 days to verify a dispute or it must be removed from your credit report. You can negotiate the removal upon final payment of the amount owed with (MORE)

If you close a credit card can a merchant still charge the account?

No, if you close your credit card, a merchant will not be able to charge the account. When the merchant attempts to get an authorization, it will come back declined. Now, if a merchant received an authorization before the card account was closed, the authorization will be honored. A merchant may a (MORE)

Should you still pay a charge off if it is off your credit report?

All depends on how old it is, some choose to walk away if the debt is beyond the SOL for legal recourse, or close to dropping off of the credit report. If that's not the case, some choose to negotiate and settle the debt for as much as 50 to 75% of the balance.

How long does a charged off credit card stay on your credit report?

Seven (7) years. Please note, a charge off does not mean a debt is not still valid and collectible by whatever means is available to the creditor/owner of the debt according to the laws of the debtor's state. Due to the current state of the economy many large credit card issuers have opted using (MORE)

Can your bank account be levied for a credit card charge off?

A charge off does not define the debt as invalid or uncollectable. It is a designation used by creditors to indicate the debt is being removed from their normal accounting methods and sent into collection action. If the creditor sues the debtor and receives a judgment (they always do) the judgment (MORE)